Skip to content

Lab study, 2007

What are the main symptom groups in premenstrual dysphoric disorder?

PMDD symptoms split into two linked groups: one combining low mood and physical symptoms, and another involving trouble with relationships and feeling out of control.

Moderate study design 632 regularly menstruating college students, mean age 24.4 years, ranging from 17 to 49

What they did

Researchers asked 632 college students about their premenstrual symptoms. They split the students randomly into two groups. For one group they used a method to find patterns in which symptoms occur together. For the other group they tested three different theories about how PMDD symptoms are organized.

What they found

The symptoms grouped into two linked dimensions. The first combined feeling depressed or irritable with physical symptoms. The second involved difficulty with relationships and feeling out of control. The two-group model fit the data better than the other two theories.

What it means for you

PMDD symptoms come in two clusters, not one pattern. This could help doctors and researchers focus on both the mood and physical sides together, and also on how the cycle affects relationships and self-control. The main limit is that this was college students without severe PMDD, not women diagnosed with the disorder.

632

students surveyed

24.4 years

mean age

About the study

Original title
Dimensionality of the premenstrual syndrome: confirmatory factor analysis of premenstrual dysphoric symptoms among college students
Authors
Wang YP, Teng CT, Vieira Filho AH et al.
Journal
Brazilian journal of medical and biological research = Revista brasileira de pesquisas medicas e biologicas
Year
2007
Study design
Lab study
Participants
316
What was tested
None; observational study
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Premenstrual syndrome and premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD) seem to form a severity continuum with no clear-cut boundary. However, since the American Psychiatric Association proposed the research criteria for PMDD in 1994, there has been no agreement about the symptomatic constellation that constitutes this syndrome. The objective of the present study was to establish the core latent structure of PMDD symptoms in a non-clinical sample. Data concerning PMDD symptoms were obtained from 632 regularly menstruating college students (mean age 24.4 years, SD 5.9, range 17 to 49). For the first random half (N = 316), we performed principal component analysis (PCA) and for the remaining half (N = 316), we tested three theory-derived competing models of PMDD by confirmatory factor analysis. PCA allowed us to extract two correlated factors, i.e., dysphoric-somatic and behavioral-impairment factors. The two-dimensional latent model derived from PCA showed the best overall fit among three models tested by confirmatory factor analysis (chi(2)53 = 64.39, P = 0.13; goodness-of-fit indices = 0.96; adjusted goodness-of-fit indices = 0.95; root mean square residual = 0.05; root mean square error of approximation = 0.03; 90%CI = 0.00 to 0.05; Akaike's information criterion = -41.61). The items "out of control" and "physical symptoms" loaded conspicuously on the first factor and "interpersonal impairment" loaded higher on the second factor. The construct validity for PMDD was accounted for by two highly correlated dimensions. These results support the argument for focusing on the core psychopathological dimension of PMDD in future studies.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics