Skip to content

Study, 2017

Do women with PMDD experience emotions differently than other women?

Only women with PMDD showed important changes in how they experienced unpleasant emotions and anxiety. The ability to recognize emotions in faces also depended on whether the face was male or female.

Early or limited evidence Women at different points of the menstrual cycle, including some with PMDD

What they did

Researchers measured mood and the ability to recognize emotions in female and male faces at four different points of the menstrual cycle (post-menstrual, ovulatory, post-ovulatory, and premenstrual). They also studied a separate group of women with PMDD during the premenstrual phase.

What they found

Only women with PMDD showed clear changes in unpleasant emotions and anxiety. All women recognized happiness and disgust best in faces, followed by surprise and sadness. Fear and anger were hardest to recognize. Happiness and surprise were recognized better on female faces, while fear and anger were recognized better on male faces. Women in the ovulatory phase and women with PMDD were better at recognizing sadness on male faces.

What it means for you

PMDD may change how women experience emotions and affect how they read feelings from other people's faces. The main limit is that the abstract does not state how many women were studied.

4

menstrual cycle phases studied

About the study

Original title
Emotional Experience and Recognition across Menstrual Cycle and in Premenstrual Disorder
Authors
Julieta Ramos‐Loyo, Araceli Sanz‐Martin
Journal
International Journal of Psychological Studies
Year
2017
Study design
Study
What was tested
None—this was observational
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

The aim of this study was to determine if differences exist in mood and in the recognition of female and male emotional faces among women in different phases of the menstrual cycle, and in women who suffer from Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder (PMDD) in the premenstrual phase. Both the emotional states and the recognition of female and male emotional faces were assessed in women in each phase of the menstrual cycle: post-menstrual, ovulatory, post-ovulatory and premenstrual. Also evaluated was a group of women who presented symptoms of PMDD during the premenstrual phase. Only the women with PMDD showed significant changes in levels of unpleasant emotions and anxiety. Regardless of group, the highest accuracy was observed for recognition of happiness and disgust, followed by surprise and sadness. The lowest level of recognition was seen for fear and anger. In addition, expressions of happiness and surprise were recognized better on female faces, while fearful and angry expressions were recognized better on male faces. Finally, women in the ovulatory phase and those with PMDD showed higher accuracy when recognizing sadness on male faces. These results suggest that only women with PMDD presented important differences in their emotional experience compared to the other groups. Finally, the gender of the emotion emitter was a factor that affected the recognition of emotions, an effect that was seen to interact slightly with the menstrual cycle phase.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics