Skip to content

Non-randomised trial, 2008

Does changing sleep timing help mood in women with PMDD?

Wake therapy improved mood in women with PMDD, but changing how early or late they slept did not work by reducing the morning melatonin hormone as researchers expected.

Early or limited evidence 19 women with PMDD and 18 control women

What they did

Researchers measured melatonin hormone levels every 30 minutes in 19 women with PMDD and 18 control women during different phases of their menstrual cycle. They tested two sleep schedules during the symptomatic phase: very early wake (sleep 3am-7am) versus late wake (sleep 9pm-1am).

What they found

Late wake therapy (sleeping 9pm-1am) changed the melatonin hormone pattern while early wake therapy (sleeping 3am-7am) did not. Both types improved mood equally. Later morning melatonin in women with PMDD was linked to worse mood, and longer melatonin duration predicted better mood improvement after late wake therapy.

What it means for you

Wake therapy helps PMDD mood, but the benefit does not come from reducing morning melatonin as researchers thought. The mood improvement must work through a different pathway. The study was small, measured only two cycle phases, and did not have a true placebo control, so the findings are preliminary.

19

Women with PMDD studied

18

Control women studied

every 30 min

Melatonin measurement frequency

About the study

Original title
Late, but not early, wake therapy reduces morning plasma melatonin: relationship to mood in Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder
Authors
Parry BL, Meliska CJ, Martínez LF et al.
Journal
Psychiatry research
Year
2008
Study design
Non-randomised trial
What was tested
Early wake therapy (sleep 3am-7am) vs late wake therapy (sleep 9pm-1am)
Open access
Yes

Topics